W [DVD]

I adored Stone's JFK film and watch it often. Nixon (the film!) was great. This movie is hugely entertaining and is to be recommended especially to sceptics. As Stone reveals in the excellent Extras, Bush is seen almost as a victim, both of his own innate stupidity but also of his clever and bullying, domineering father. What comes through is Dubya's total adoration of/by his wife; his faith in god which (he thinks) renders him invincible and infallible, and his belief that he genuinely wanted to do good during his presidency. Stone interweaves Bush' wild youth with the run-up to the Iraq war. The 'Michael Moore' treatment is, for example, the Robin Hood music (hilarious) while Bush debates military strategy; the caricature treatment of Condoleeza Rice and some of the camera work. I was very impressed with this film, having almost been put off by critics. If you have an opinion of Blair and Bush and the Iraq invasion, this is a good piece of critique. Bet you end up feeling sorry for Bush!!!

For anyone wanting a Bush bashing Michael Moore type movie then this fair minded film is not for you ! The people behind this interesting film have done right by open-minded viewers as it shows how George W Bush became the man that he is. He had a struggle with drink & not being able to hold down a job while having to compete with his brother Jeb for their Dad's affection. The cast do an excellent job depicting Rumsfeld , Cheney , Rice et al and Josh Brolin just has George W Bush to a tee. It is tragic that a man who set out to do good ended up with such problems - the well written script makes this very clear. There is much pathos & drama but with just enough wry humor to help things along. The editing is clever as it shows recent events of the Bush presidency and things from his past thus showing how he ended up being the man he is and why he did what he did. It could have been a mish-mash but thanks to the editors skill the movie flows very well indeed. For someone who wants to understand the Bush presidency and the man himself this is not a bad place to start.Amazon are selling this for a good price and so is a worthy addition to a drama lovers DVD collection.

Like Stones' other biopics of american presidents this is very well crafted. Josh Brolin does a great job starring as Bush jr, and in some scenes he is eerily lookalike. The film alternates between the time just before the invasion of Iraq, and episodes from W:s reckless youth. We get snapshots from the White House, Bushs talks with Powell, Rice, Rumsfeld, Rove and, of course, Cheney. The latter being the important man behind it all is being made clear. We also get episodes from W:s alcoholism, his "rebirth" and most important: the relationship with Bush senior. The heart of the story seems to be this relationship, where senior favors Jeb and find Jr hard to deal with, and where Jr feels patronized and so on. Actually I wonder how true this really is, I mean how much does Stone know about this? And isn't it unethical to speculate about another living man's psyche and shortcomings in a major movie like this, even if it it a former president? The events seems a little too recent for that. Of course, Stone doesn't sink to the garbage level of Michael Moore in this, and all in all the portrait is not wholly unsympathetic. Bush is not depicted as a scoundrel or demonised here. But still...

Oliver Stone brings his undeniable talent to this biopic of George `Dubya' Bush.. supported by one of those to-die-for casts he seems to have at his beck and call. There's no question this is slickly put together, and that Josh Brolin is completely convincing as the title character .... but as a movie experience there is just something missing. Stone presents Bush as a follower rather than a leader. Someone who is driven by being under the shadow of his brother in his parents eyes, and whose political drive to succeed is a mirror of his drive to succeed in his father's eyes. Surrounding him, we have a veritable who's who of Hollywood acting as all the well known string pullers behind him and around him - most of whom are thinly drawn, not being the centre of attention - but of all of them, Richard Dreyfuss does a surprisingly good job of fleshing out Dick Cheney. There's a little jolt of energy whenever he has a moment on screen, particularly sparring with Colin Powell. But these are asides, with W's evolving character being the focus, and so as the movie goes on, we see Bush at different times of his life. From College pranks through trying to find a job he wants to keep, meeting Laura, becoming born again (watch out for a great Stacey Keach turn) and starting his political career.. all told non linearly, interspersed with the period of time that will dominate his place in history - going to war with Iraq. With all those fine ingredients however, it seems that something has been left out - some excitement, some dramatic hook to draw you in. Frankly, Bush's life, rather like his presidency some would argue, is rather dull. In the end, the enjoyment of the movie is in the details.. enjoying watching for Hollywood well known faces playing political well known faces, learning a little about Dubya's earlier life. But we don't come away much richer for the experience. Stone's interpretation of the man is valid, but never feels insightful enough or definitive, neither does it have the cinematic or dramatic energy of, say, `Nixon'. It's not a disaster, but neither does it sparkle. Sometimes interesting, never fascinating. Perhaps it is too soon, and looking back in twenty years or more this will be regarded in higher esteem.

As with NIXON, (Anthony Hopkins), American really can pick "them." This idiot couldn't spell potato, and sat like a dummy on 9/11, in front of a class of children NOT knowing what to do. NUFF said. A good film though, well worth a watch.

Love all Oliver stones work

All good thanks

Ich habe mir "W" aus reinem Interesse an der Person des George W. Bush angesehen. Es gibt ja fast nur Negatives über den Sohn von George Bush zu lesen, zu sehen, zu hören. Aber ich gehöre ja zu den Menschen, die sich gerne beiden Seiten einer Münze angucken, bevor sie ein Urteil fällen. Ich bin ein Fan von Oliver Stone Verfilmungen und nach diesem Film musste ich dann erstmal in mich gehen. Der Dabbelju, der uns hier präsentiert wird, ist ein menschlicher, ein sogar recht amüsanter und sympathischer Mann, der ganz ehrlich überzeugt von dem gewesen ist, was er während seiner Amtszeit so getan hat. Das kann man jetzt gutheißen oder auch nicht, das muß jeder für sich selbst entscheiden. Man kann nach dem Film auch versuchen, den Menschen "W" vom Politiker "W" zu trennen, aber das erweist sich als fast unmöglich, weil sein Werdegang zu politisch ist, als das man das eine vom anderen trennen könnte. Im Grund ist der Herr W. Bush ein Kind seiner Zeit und vor allem ein Kind seines allumfassenden Vaters. W. ist ein lustiger junger Mann, er trinkt gerne, er lacht gerne, er macht gerne mit Frauen rum, Arbeit ist nicht so sein Ding. Er leidet unter dem Herrscherdruck des Vaters, der den jüngeren Sohn Jeb stets vorzieht. Egal, was er tut, er wird den Erwartungen nicht gerecht, das macht ihn sympathisch. Kennt man die familiären Hintergründe kann man einige Entscheidungen, die Herr W. Bush in seiner Amtszeit getroffen hat, besser verstehen. Man muss sie nicht gutheißen, aber man kann sie nachvollziehen. Allen voran in Einmarsch in den Irak. In Oliver Stones Film lernt man den Menschen Walker Bush kennen. Man kann über ihnen weinen und ihn belächeln, aber man der Film macht eins deutlich: Der Führer der Welt ist immer in erster Linie ein Mensch und als solcher fehlbar! Josh Brolin vergisst man fast, wenn man den Film guckt, er wird zu Bush, was auch ein großes Plus für den Film ist. Angucken und selbst urteilen.

Malgré les mauvaises critiques des médias, ''W.'' reste un très bon film superbement bien fait. Bien sûr, ce n'est pas ''JFK'' mais cela tire très bien son épingle du jeu. Josh Brolin est excellent dans le rôle du président Bush. Les prestations de James Cromwell (George Bush père), Richard Dreyfuss (Dick Cheney) et Stacey Keach (le révérend Hurle) sont également à souligner. Le film raconte la genèse de la guerre d'Irak de 2003 et la façon dont le gouvernement Bush s'y est pris pour justifier cette guerre controversée. Il revient également dans le passé, à l'époque où Bush était alcoolique. La réaction du président lorsqu'il apprend que l'Irak n'a pas d'armes de destruction massive est à voir. Oliver Stone nous donne sa façon de voir l'histoire récente des États-Unis. Un film à voir et à revoir.

a good insight into W

Grande come sempre Oliver Stone il film è eccezionale Non a caso Non lo vedrete mai né in televisione né sulle varie piattaforme

Super!