Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Navy, 1 count

This is the first time interacting with this seller and I’m happy to say I received my eyeliner on time and ik perfect condition. Recently I had dealt with another seller and two different items shipped two different times were broken with THAT seller however this seller did a splendid job and I couldn’t be happier! The eyeliner works great, it doesn’t irritate my eyes , color is as described and I would definitely order from this seller again! After my initial first orders with another seller having received a broken eyeliner and a broken eyeshadow on two separate occasions I am so very happy to be dealing with a seller who ships promptly, wraps the product well and the item is as described. I would definitely recommend dealing with this seller from my first order and how smoothly it went ! The Almay navy eyeliner is easy to apply, a perfect navy and doesn’t irritate my eyes.

Really pretty color, goes on nicely but I will caution you to make sure that if you don't want a solid obvious "line" to blend right away or it gets a little more challenging to blend well otherwise. Wears well and all day, never need to reapply. I do not have any problems with it smudging or running, once it's on, it stays put. Washes off nice and easily and if during the day I forget and slightly wipe at my eye, it doesn't smudge either...my mascara on the other hand....that's another review. I like this product and will order again. I have sensitive eyes and this doesn't bother me at all!! I've tried so many "natural" or organic products out there but Almay always comes through. I just wish their eye shadows were better and had better selections.

I use it as an eyeliner. The color (navy) is great and stays without smudging. I would give an overall 5 star, but the sharpening is kind of cumbersome. I will buy again, because the color is deep, and , again, even during exercises with lots of perspiration, the color doe not run. Really a great eyeliner!

This product arrived broken, but has a "no return" policy, so I'm stuck with it. On arrival, the center "lead" was way out, and stuck inside the plastic cover. When I tried to push it back in, it wouldn't go back. When I, finally just pulled it out, I saw that it was already broken half-way down. I should have read the negative reviews more carefully. This does NOT extend with a twist of the wand, it is supposed to be sharpened with a pencil sharpener, even though it is described as "Gel Smooth Eyeliner". I'm baffled by the positive reviews, but maybe earlier versions of the product are better. I just wasted $7.45 for the navy eyeliner. I'm used to better treatment by Amazon. Very disappointing.

Loved that it was so easy to apply. As the name implies, it glides on the eyelid. It does have long lasting staying power; however, it ran out after using it for only a few weeks.

Great gel liner. Bad reputation. I like everyone else purchased this creamy, liner and it worked great until the tip wore out. I spent quite a while trying to twist the top to extend the liner. I finally gave up and put in a request for a return. The seller wrote back it was denied and stated it just needs to be sharpened. Being ‘Old School’ I looked in my makeup bag a found an old sharpener! And Voilá! A new tip! I would give 5 stars but the seller needs to take the time to let folks know this simple step. Save many a lot of trouble!

I've been having a lot of allergic reactions to eye makeup recently, so I have been searching for some hypoallergenic eyeliner, pencil and mascara. I'm pretty pleased with this liner overall, and although it does make my eyes feel a little itchy for a few minutes after application, it doesn't cause any redness, wateriness or swelling. However, I wouldn't recommend using it for your waterline. Try to keep it at where your bottom lash line starts and gradually smudge/re-apply the liner until you have achieved the desired look. All in all, I like it!

Goes on without pulling and stays on. Took longer to receive than most Amazon products.